Legal

New, stricter rules against greenwashing are coming

By: Tereza Pitterlingová

Contents

The Chamber of Deputies has approved an amendment to the Consumer Protection Act and the Civil Code, which specifies the conditions for the use of environmental claims and product sustainability labels and strengthens consumer protection against their artificial obsolescence. Its main goal is to eradicate greenwashing, i.e. communication that creates false or misleading information. impression of the product's environmental impact. The planned legislative amendments are based on the European Directive 2024/825 on empowering consumers in the context of the green transition by better protecting them against unfair practices and by providing better information, also known as the EmpCo Directive, which was to be implemented by the Member States from March this year. The amendment has not yet gone through the entire legislative process.

What will change for manufacturers? Fewer green promises, more specific information

It will no longer be so easy to label a product as “ecological“ or “environmentally friendly“. New rules against greenwashing will tighten the way companies communicate the environmental impacts of their products, and strengthen the information about their lifespan and repairability. The rules apply not only to manufacturers, but also to retailers and other businesses that communicate with consumers. Below we summarize the main changes being prepared:

1.     „eco“ on the packaging alone is not enough

General claims such as „green“, „ecological“ or „environmentally friendly“ will be possible can only be used if the entrepreneur demonstrates a recognised excellent environmental profile relevant to the claim. The basis may only be the EU Ecolabel or another officially recognised national or regional type I eco-label scheme according to EN ISO 14024 (e.g. environmentally friendly product). However, it will always depend on what properties it actually certifies. Another option would be a too general slogan should be replaced by specific, truthful and demonstrable information and this specification should be clearly and prominently defined on the same communication medium, for example on the packaging. A mere reference to an explanation elsewhere may not be sufficient. For example, instead of a vague "ecological packaging", it would be necessary to state "the plastic body of the bottle contains 80% recycled plastic, the cap and label are not included", if these values ​​can be substantiated.

2.     Own „ green& “certificate“ is not trustworthy 

Voluntary sustainability labelling will have to be based on a certification system or introduced by a public authority. It will not be enough to create your own green certificate and base its credibility solely on your own assessment. The certification system should have publicly available rules and objective requirements, be accessible under transparent, fair and non-discriminatory conditions, and be to entrepreneurs who comply with them, and include independent third-party verification and procedures for non-compliance, including suspension or removal of labels. The rule also applies to labels referring to social characteristics, not just environmental ones. A proprietary logo, such as "Our Green Choice", which a retailer uses to label selected products according to internal criteria without any accountability certification, will not be sufficient. The decisive factor will not be whether the brand is private, but whether it meets the specified conditions. Moreover, even a certified logo will not be able to create a broader impression than what the certification actually covers.

3.     Ecological packaging does not mean an ecological product

If the benefit only concerns the packaging or one component, this must be clear from the communication. An entrepreneur may not give the impression that an entire product or company is sustainable if the claim actually relates to only a partial feature or activity. The overall tone of the message will be decisive. For example, in the case of cosmetics in a box made of recycled paper, it will not be possible to present the entire product as "made from recycled materials" just because of the box, or it will not be possible to claim that the entire company uses recycled materials. exclusively renewable energy, if this applies to only one establishment. The scope of the claim will have to correspond to the scope of the actually proven benefit.

4.     The carbon neutrality of a product cannot be built on offsets alone

Claims that a product has a neutral, reduced or positive impact on greenhouse gas emissions will be prohibited if they are based on offsets. The purchase of carbon credits (offsets) will therefore not entitle a product to be labelled as “climate neutral”. This prohibition cannot be circumvented by adding a certain actual reduction in emissions to the compensation, if the final claim is still based on their inclusion. For example, air travel cannot be offered as a “CO₂-neutral flight” just because the carrier finances tree planting or purchases credits to offset emissions. It will still be possible to truthfully inform about the support of climate projects if the communication does not give the impression that the impacts of a specific product or service have been eliminated. It is also possible to document claims about the actual reduction of emissions in the product's life cycle, with a clear definition of the comparison, period and methodology.

5.     Compliance with legal sustainability requirements cannot be presented as a special advantage

A requirement imposed by law on all products in a given category on the EU market cannot be presented as a special advantage for one's own offer. It is not just about sustainability: the rule is generally intended to prevent an entrepreneur from presenting a mandatory standard as a purely voluntary extra measure. If the law prohibited the use of certain substances in all products of a certain category on the EU market, the seller should not claim that, unlike other manufacturers, it protects nature because its product does not contain this substance. Such a statement would create an unjustified impression of advantage over competitors who must comply with the same prohibition. It will depend on the manner of presentation, mere information on the composition or compliance with the requirement is not the same as promoting it as an exceptional product. benefits.

6.     Concrete and verifiable promises about an ecological future

Also, promises of future improvements in terms of environmental impact will need more than marketing ambition. The new regulation will require that these commitments be clear, objective, publicly available and verifiable, and captured in in a detailed and realistic implementation plan with measurable and time-bound objectives. Their fulfilment will then be regularly verified by an independent expert, whose findings will be available to consumers. A slogan such as "by 2030 we will halve emissions" will not be sufficient without specifying the emissions concerned, specific measures and a timetable according to the new rules. The entrepreneur will have to explain whether this is an absolute emissions or emissions per unit of production, which activities are targeted, how it is financed and how progress is monitored.

7.     Manufacturers must not misrepresent durability, repairs and upgrades

The rules also target false claims about the durability or repairability of a product. It will not be possible to conceal the negative impacts of upgrades, promise a certain durability in normal use, present an unrepairable product as repairable, or encourage the replacement of consumables earlier than is necessary for technical reasons. Such practices will be considered deceptive commercial practices under the prepared amendment to the Civil Code. Commercial communications about goods containing a deliberately introduced lifespan-limiting feature (so-called planned obsolescence) will also be prohibited if the entrepreneur is informed about this element and its effects.

They are to be expanded also pre-contractual information. The consumer shall obtain information on the repairability score, if this is provided for by EU rules for the goods in question, otherwise, under the conditions laid down, information made available by the manufacturer on the availability, estimated costs and ordering procedure of spare parts, repair and maintenance instructions or repair restrictions. For goods with digital elements, this shall also include the minimum repairability score communicated by the manufacturer. period of providing the necessary free software updates.

The amendment under preparation is intended to strengthen the requirement that information on the sustainability, durability and repairability of products be specific, truthful and demonstrable. Manufacturers and sellers should therefore promptly check their marketing claims, labels used and information provided to customers and identify whether they are committing greenwashing. The final scope of the obligations however, it will depend on the outcome of the legislative process.

This text was translated by AI.