Legal

Supreme Court: transfer of shares before the formation of a limited liability company is possible

By: Jan Pluháček

Contents

The Supreme Court, in its resolution of 3 June 2026, file no. 27 Cdo 3437/2024, addressed the question of whether a contract for the transfer of a share in a limited liability company can be validly concluded between its foundation and its formation. In the case under consideration, the sole founder concluded a contract on the day of the foundation of the company, by which she transferred half of her future share to a third party. The registry and appellate courts The court considered such a contract to be absolutely invalid due to the initial impossibility of performance, because at the time of its conclusion the company had not yet been established, and therefore there was no share that was to be the subject of the transfer. However, the Supreme Court did not agree with this legal assessment.

According to the Supreme Court, a distinction must be made between the existence of a share and the possibility of concluding a contract whose subject is a future share. A share is created only upon the establishment of the company, i.e. its entry in the commercial register, this fact in itself does not prevent the founder from committing to a future transfer of shares before that moment. In this context, the Supreme Court relied, among other things, on Section 1760 of the Civil Code, according to which the fact that a party is not authorized to dispose of the thing that is to be the subject of performance when concluding a contract does not in itself render the contract invalid. At the same time, he reminded that the initial impossibility of performance leads to invalidity under Section 580, Paragraph 2 of the Civil Code only if performance is actually impossible.

A contract for the transfer of a future share can therefore be validly concluded even before the establishment of the limited liability company. However, the acquirer cannot acquire ownership of the share before the share itself is established. Unless otherwise agreed, the share is therefore acquired at the time of the establishment of the company. The effects of the transfer against the company must be distinguished from the acquisition of ownership rights. According to Section 209, Paragraph 2 of the Commercial Corporations Act, these occur upon delivery of an effective share transfer agreement with the company's officially certified signatures. The Supreme Court also accepted that if the transferor is also the company's first executive director, these effects may be associated with the date of incorporation of the company, provided that the relevant conditions are met.

Decision has practical significance, especially for structuring the entry of investors into newly established companies. Founders do not necessarily have to wait until the company is registered in the commercial register to conclude a share transfer agreement, but can contractually regulate the transfer of the future share in advance. Such a procedure may be appropriate, for example, if the ownership structure of the company immediately after its establishment is to differ from the structure recorded in the company's financial statements. in the founding legal proceedings. The decision thus brings greater flexibility in setting the future ownership structure of the company during its foundation.

Even in light of this decision, the transfer of a future share cannot be considered a purely formal matter. In the transaction documentation, it is appropriate to clearly define the future share as the subject of the transfer, adjust the moment of acquisition, and ownership rights and also remember the situation when the company ultimately does not come into existence for any reason. At the same time, it is necessary to respect the legal and statutory restrictions on transferability, any requirements for the consent of the company's bodies, the rules for the division of shares and the form of the contract prescribed by law. The decision of the Supreme Court thus confirms the possibility of contractually preparing the transfer of a future share before the company is established, while at the same time emphasizing the importance of the precise setting of individual transaction steps and their time-binding nature.

This text was translated by AI.